Ontology is the study and investigation of the nature of existence, especially of what kinds of things exist, and related topics. Ontological questions in the philosophy of jazz are of the general form: WHAT is this? Does it exist or not? What are its features and properties?
- Click or tap on any subheading of the Contents Outline and you are taken to that section on this page.
- Click or tap on any Question/Topic and its page opens up. Any words below colored in bold in these instructions are hot links to the area designated. Click or tap on them to go to that area.
- If you have submitted your email in the Join Us link (located in the upper right corner on the top of the HOME page menu bar or under the Navigation menu on top left of each page) and have clicked on received a confirmation reply email, you may then edit the website as a writer/editor.
- To Login as a writer/editor, click on Personal located at the top left of the page, then click on login. To upload an image it must be either a .jpg, .jpeg, .png, or .gif and preferably a Creative Commons Zero (CC0) license. This means the pictures are completely free to be used for any legal purpose and free for personal and even commercial use. They can be modified, copied and distributed without asking for permission or setting a link to the source, so that attribution is not required. Click on the Tools menu bar located at top of page on right then fifth item down that says Upload file. Please read under the Wiki menu (located on home page or under Navigation menu), PoJ.fm's Format Philosophy for the Procedures and Protocols for uploading an image.
Andrew Kania, in his article, "Do Higher-Order Musical Ontologies Rest On A Mistake: A Reply to Lee Brown"starts by making an important distinction for ontologists: fundamental versus higher-order ontologies.
“Musical ontologists study the kinds of musical things there are—works, performances, recordings, and so on—and the relationships that hold between them. I have argued that there is a useful distinction to be drawn between two projects in this field. ‘Fundamental’ musical ontology is the study of the basic metaphysical categories into which musical entities fall. (This project usually takes works and performances of Western classical music, more or less broadly construed, and more or less explicitly, as its target.) ‘Higher-order’ musical ontology asks questions that can be answered independently of a fundamental musical-ontological theory, such as what conditions must be met in order for a performance to be of a given work.”
- Ontmusic000 Table of Abbreviations for Musical Instruments
- Ontmusic00. Music Basics
- Ontmusic0. What is music?
- Ontmusic1. What is a musical work?
- Ontmusic2. Does jazz have/contain musical works?
- Ontmusic3. What is a song?
- Ontmusic4. Are musical works eternal types?
- Ontmusic5. When are two musical examples of the same song?
- Ontmusic6. What is a musical arrangement?
- Ontmusic7. What is a musical genre?
- Ontmusic8. What is a musical score?
- Ontmusic9. What is a musical performance?
- Ontmusic10. What is singing?
- Ontmusic11. What is sonicism?
- Ontmusic12. Music and Emotion
- Ontmusic13. What is melody?
- Ontmusic14. Are musical works of a single kind?
- Ontmusic15. Are free improvisations best regarded as performances of ephemeral works?
- Ontmusic16. Can two composers working independently create the same, single piece?
- Ontmusic17. Do composers discover or create their compositions?
- Ontmusic18. Of what elements are musical works comprised?
- Ontmusic19. Is there more to a piece than its sound sequence?
- Ontmusic20. How are works specified by notations?
- Ontmusic21. Is everything recorded in the score work-identifying and, hence, required in an accurate performance?
- Ontmusic22. What conditions must be satisfied if a performance is to be of a particular piece?
- Ontmusic23. Can performances that sound different faithfully represent and be of a single work?
- Ontmusic24. Can performances that sound the same faithfully represent and be of different pieces?
- Ontmusic25. Can a performance simultaneously be of more than one work?
- Ontmusic26. Critique of Nelson Goodman's Perfection Requirement for Song Identity
- Ontmusic27. Slow Music
- Ontmusic28. Bad Music: What makes it bad?
- Ontmusic29. Good Music: What makes it good?
- Ontmusic30. What is syncopation?
- Ontmusic31. What is new music?
- Ontmusic32. What are Jazz sub-genres?
- Ontmusic test
- Ontmeta0. What is the philosophy of jazz?
- Ontmusic0. What is music?
- Ontmeta2. What is silence?
- Ontmeta3. What is noise?
- Ontmeta4. What is listening?
- Ontmeta5. Does jazz have emergent properties?
- Ontmeta6. What is sound?
- Ontmeta7. Kinds and Jazz
- Ontmeta0. Test page
- Ontmeta00. Test page
- Ontmeta000.Test page
- Ontmeta0001.Test page
- Ontmeta0000. Test page
- Ontmeta00000. Test page
- Ontmeta00005. Test page
- Ontmeta000000. Test page
- Ontimpr0. Bibliography on Jazz Improvisation with some Abstracts
- Ontimpr1. What is improvisation?
- Ontimpr2. Is the best improvisation inferior to the best composition?
- Ontimpr3. What is a mistake?
- Ontimpr4. On mistakes and improvisation
- Ontimpr5. Scientific investigations of improvisation
- Ontimpr6. Improvisation and Education
- Ontimpr7. Can Improvisation be taught?
- Ontimpr8. The complexity of improvisation
- Ontimpr9. How two substantial jazz improvisations could be identical
- Ontimpr10. Improvisation and Composition
- Ontimpr11. Is Improvisation Essential to Jazz?
- Ontimpr12. Positive Evaluations of Good Improvisations
- Ontpj1. What is a combo?
- Ontpj2. What is an orchestra?
- Ontpj3. What is a conductor and what does she do to conduct?
- Ontpj4. What is the ideal jazz musician like?
- Ontpj5. What is the jazz canon?
- Ontpj6. What differences and similarities exist between a solo performance and a group performance?
- Ontpj7. What is standard jazz harmony?
- Ontpj8. What intentions does a jazz improviser have?
- Ontpj9. Bad jazz: What makes it bad?
- Ontpj10. Good jazz: What makes it good?
- MetaA5. What is the language of jazz?
- MetaA6. Objections to jazz having or being a language
- Ontpj11. What traits are most admired in jazz legends regarding their jazz prowess?
- Ontdef1. What is a definition?
- Ontdef2. Arguments for the impossibility of defining jazz
- Ontdef3. What is the definition of jazz?
- Ontdef4. Unhelpful definitions of jazz
- Ontdef5. Is free jazz jazz?
- Ontdef6. What are the differences between Dixieland and Bebop?
- Ontdef7. Features of jazz and definition of terms
- Ontdef8. What is a bicycle?
- Onttech1. What is the groove?
- Onttech2. What is swing?
- Onttech3. What are rhythm changes?
- Onttech4. What is a vocalization?
- Onttech5. What is scat singing?
- Onttech6. What is syncopation?
- Onttech7. How does jazz use the blues?
- Onttech8. Jazz Composition
- Onttech9. Jazz Composition
Ontology: Types of Jazz & Related Musics
Internet Resources on Ontology
- On Ontology and Information Science, preprint version of chapter “Ontology," in L. Floridi (ed.), Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of Computing and Information, Oxford: Blackwell, 2003, pp. 155–166.
- Andrew Kania, "New Waves in Musical Ontology" in K. Stock and K. Thomson-Jones (eds.), New Waves in Aesthetics, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008, pp. 20–40. “‘Higher-order musical ontology’ is quite a mouthful, but acronymizing the phrase seems like a bad idea.”